I love butter. Everyone loves butter. It rules. But the average guy (including me) doesn’t actually know much about it. Where did it come from? How is it made? What are the different kinds? And is it even bad for you? All a mystery.
All of these are questions that absolutely must be answered. I mean, its butter! It’s delicious, delectable, versatile, and straight up awesome. And, it has a story.
Where Did Butter Come From
Believe it or not, no one actually knows exactly where, or when butter originated. But there’s evidence butter is as ancient as people. The Romans used butter for all kinds of things and butter is even mentioned in the Bible during the Patriarchal Era.
While we might not know exactly where it came from, we have some idea. As the legend goes, it came from an ancient nomadic tribe somewhere in Northern Europe.
And there’s a plausible explanation of its discovery. The rumor is, a Nomad put the milk of an animal in a sheepskin bag, then strapped that bag to his horse. After some travelling, and the bag bobbing up and down during the journey, it accidentally created butter.
The Nomads figured out what was going on, and it eventually became their preferred fat. The ancient Greeks even called some Northern Europeans “butter eaters” as a derogatory term. Silly Greeks.
So, how exactly did a Nomad accidentally make one of the most delicious things humans have ever tasted?
How Butter is Made
Making butter is insanely simple. But there are two different ways it’s can be made: homemade & factory made.
The factory ways obviously heavily processed, but it’s really the same idea.
Commercial butter is just produced directly from raw cow’s milk.
The milk is taken from the farm to the factory, where it’s placed in a big ass centrifuge, which spins the fat out of the milk. What’s used for the butter is called “butter cream”, the left-over liquid is used and processed as skim milk.
They pasteurize the butter cream, and then it’s churned in a mechanical churner. The whole point of churning butter cream is to combine the fat molecules, which makes clumpy butter. That clumpy butter is smoothened, shaped, and packaged, then it’s wisked off to the grocery stores.
Then there’s the homemade version, which is almost the same. Except homemade, you use heavy cream, and just throw it in a small churner. You spin the churner, until it forms butter. It’s that easy.
If you don’t have one of those mini churners, you can just use a food processor. Throw the cream in there and process away. Easy peasey.
Types of Butter
Whenever we think of butter, we just think of the simple Land o Lakes bar of butter. But apparently, there are many types. Without going into a long-winded list of butters, he’s a short-winded list of butters.
Salted & Unsalted Butter
This is your basic, conventional bar of butter. Either they add salt or they don’t. Easy. Simple. Elegant.
Organic Butter
Made from Organic Cow’s Milk. The cows are fed only organic feed and/or grass. Obviously, since it’s organic it’s going to be a little cleaner. But this butter doesn’t differentiate that much from regular salted or unsalted butter.
Grass Fed Butter
This is the kind I use. The cows who produce this milk eat a 100% grass fed diet. As opposed to just organic where it could be lot feed. Grass fed butter, unlike organic, is completely different. The color, the taste, the texture, are all unique. Plus, this goes great in everything and it’s awesome for cooking.
Whipped Butter
This kind of butter has some sort of gas, usually nitrogen, added to it. It’s less dense, so that increases the volume. It’s a lighter butter. It’s good for bread and things like that. Never use it to cook. Unless you want to meat the local fireman.
Spreadable Butter
Most of the time, this is butter with added vegetable oil. And often it’s not healthy. Sometimes companies will use some mix of butter and vegetable oil, or some other kind of hydrogenated vegetable oil. Avoid “spreadable” butter.
European Style Butter
I feel like I never see this one. But it’s used in pastries, like croissants, things like that. The difference with this one is it uses high fat milk (about 85% fat). That’s why it’s used in pastries, it creates an awesome flakey coat when baked.
Clarified Butter
You’ll see this at Whole Foods or other health food stores. It’s butter, but with all the milk solids removed. What you have leftover is basically pure butterfat. It’s great for cooking or if you have a lactose issue.
Is Butter Bad For You?
Unfortunately, we’re just going to scratch the surface here. There are whole books written about this. The saturated fat debate.
I’m in the saturated fat camp, because there truly isn’t any proof that saturated fat causes any problems, in of itself.
Anyways, butter can be loaded with vitamins and nutrients too. There are a bunch of goodies hiding in butter. It has all kinds of vitamins such as Vitamin A, D, E and even K2. There’s even trace minerals hiding underneath those vitamins. Things like zinc, chromium, copper, manganese, and selenium.
Grass fed butter is even better than traditional butter. Their butter is cleaner, and it has denser concentrations of Conjugated Lineolic Acid, which is super beneficial. CLA has been shown to help you lose fat, maintain weight loss, retain lean muscle mass, and control type 2 diabetes.
The point of this article wasn’t to do a deep dive on the health benefits of butter, I just wanted to lay out a few points. If you’re disappointed, I’ll have a whole butter health article coming your way soon.
Final Thoughts
I said it once, and I’ll say it again. Butter rules. I eat it every day. In my coffee, on my steak, on my potatoes, you name it.
I’m also fat adapted, and for me, it’s not a dangerous endeavor. But please be careful, if you are eating a lot of carbs, and generally eating like crap, not exercising, then eating loads of butter is probably not a great idea.
However, by itself, butter is not unhealthy. Which is why it’s such a huge part of my diet, and my life. I’ve tried almost every single kind of butter except European. My hands down favorite is Grass fed and it’s what I buy when I go grocery shopping.
I think it goes well with everything and it’s great to cook with at low to medium temperatures. I’m a one butter kind of guy, but you can always use certain butters for certain things.
What I was blown away by was how easy it is to make butter. Just buy some cream, and a churner, throw in some salt, and in twenty minutes you have yourself, fresh, homemade butter. It’s awesome.
Hopefully now you have a better full view on butter, and now you can gloat and say you know where butter comes from.
References
19/01/2016, Posted by Brendon O’Neill. “How Is Butter Made? Factory Vs Homemade.” Canstar Blue, 28 Oct. 2018, www.canstarblue.co.nz/food-drink/how-butter-is-made/.
Jade, GF. “How Is Butter Made?” Graham’s Family Dairy, 24 Nov. 2016, www.grahamsfamilydairy.com/news-events/blog/how-butter-made.
Gold, Betty. “The 9 Most Common Types of Butter-and the Best Way to Use Them.” Real Simple, 2020, www.realsimple.com/food-recipes/shopping-storing/food/types-of-butter.
Romero, Catherine. “Is Butter Actually Good For You?” StyleBlueprint, 15 Sept. 2015, styleblueprint.com/everyday/is-butter-actually-good-for-you-yes/.
Smith, Michael W. “CLA (Conjugated Linoleic Acid) Weight Loss Supplements.” WebMD, WebMD, 24 May 2004, www.webmd.com/diet/news/20040520/cla-weight-loss.
The Ages, Butter T. “How Do You Make Butter.” How Do You Make Butter? : Butter, 28 Oct. 2020, www.webexhibits.org/butter/making.html.
Wetzel, Alisa. “The History of Butter.” Butter Journal, 2017, www.butterjournal.com/butter-history.
